How Authentic Marketing Drives Real Customer Connections

The Gist

• Refocus on people. Authentic marketing means prioritizing genuine human connections rather than just optimizing content for algorithms or metrics.

• Embrace imperfection. Experimentation and creative risk-taking can help brands stand out in an overly optimized, templated marketing landscape.

• Balance data with humanity. Leverage insights from metrics while keeping storytelling, empathy and personalized customer connections at the forefront.

Marketing has become hyper-focused on data — mostly for good reason.

With the rise of performance-based marketing and an emphasis on precision through an increasingly viable set of CX analytic tools, today’s marketing strategies have arguably never been more data-driven.

Using this abundance of data, companies can fine-tune their digital campaigns and optimize everything including clicks, lead conversions and sales. This allows marketing leaders to show a seemingly direct and measurable line that drives revenue.

Adding to this data-obsessed ecosystem are new and potent marketing platforms — mainly social media platforms — that can help marketers target campaigns with ever greater precision. What’s more, the rise of generative AI has supercharged marketers’ ability to create content fast while keeping platform-driven distribution models in focus. This helps them create content designed specifically for targeted distribution and audience engagement.

In an industry that traditionally has had a difficult time truly quantifying its efforts to the C-suite, marketing leaders finally are coming to the table with impressive data-based tools and strategies, which gives them newfound respect and status.

Is This Marketing Really Authentic?

Such hyper-algorithmic digital marketing, however, is starting to leave a sour taste in my mouth.

There is undoubtedly a place for such performance-based marketing. Using data and technology to improve processes and strategy in any field is something every business leader should want to have at their disposal.

Still, today’s environment is evolving at such a fast pace that it feels like it’s hastily bypassing the human creative elements of marketing that powerfully help brands connect with their customers authentically. Somewhere along the way, it seems like we stopped creating marketing content for people and now exclusively create marketing content for robots.

Marketers, to be sure, should embrace digital tools and modern frameworks like search engine optimization (SEO) and programmatic social media advertising, while largely adhering to the common guidelines that have led to proven best practices in these areas.

Yet today’s content marketing ecosystem feels overly optimized. From copy length to keyword density to UX design, marketing content is now so templated and formulaic that almost nothing seems original or, dare I say, interesting. Few companies have differentiated marketing because they’re all obsessively following the same set of algorithmic-based rules.

What results is marketing content that is repetitive and sometimes boring. Embracing these tools and frameworks should also be balanced with genuine human connection as a strategic guide. Instead of relying wholly on Google search trends to build an editorial content calendar, for instance, have conversations with real users and customers about the issues that are important to them.

Accumulating metrics through hyper-algorithmic marketing may stuff the stat sheet with gaudy numbers, but hidden amid the dashboards may be a lot of empty calories of ultimately meaningless engagement.

With this in mind, here are six ways to make sure that authentic marketing, genuine human connection and unique storytelling remain a priority in marketing.

1. Refocus on the Core Purpose of Marketing

This starts with reminding ourselves why we are creating content and who we are developing campaigns for. For marketers, there are many metrics to help support revenue key performance indicators (KPI) such as clicks and keywords to conversions. However, we must not forget the needs of our final audience.

If we’re fixated on finding the most efficient path to capturing a new lead, we risk overlooking ways in which we can create lasting, valuable, trustworthy relationships with our customers.

2. Step Outside the Digital Echo Chamber

Marketers often operate within their digital silos. Social media managers master LinkedIn while SEO specialists navigate the complexities of Google. But how often do they step beyond these channels to engage directly with the people they aim to reach?

I encourage teams to go out there and talk to our customers. As a marketer in the construction industry, I make this a priority. I speak to those who are working on the frontlines at job sites so that I can connect with our customers and understand their needs and challenges.

When you put yourself in your customers’ shoes — sometimes literally — you gain insights that go beyond the digital realm and that can help bring trust and authentic marketing into future campaigns.

3. Show the Impact, Don’t Tell

A common trap that many marketers fall into is diving straight into customer problem solving. While pushing the merits and benefits of a product to your audience is important, relating to their challenges is even more essential. Leading with empathy and leveraging stories that speak to a shared experience is a key principle of authentic marketing, and it will spark a genuine connection between your brand and your customers.

A good example of this is the popular Naked Wines’ campaign, which invited customers to “test” their knowledge of good wine, a conversation that many people, myself included, can relate to. Instead of pushing a sales message, they created a fun and engaging brand-agnostic experience that ended with a showcasing of wines to suit the customers’ specific preferences. 

These kinds of interactions are valuable. Campaigns that involve the customer and speak directly to their interests feel more personalized, and we live in a world where personalized CX is key.

Related Article: 6 Ways to Get Customer Buy-In for Your Marketing Campaigns

4. Leverage the Full Spectrum of Metrics

While bottom-line numbers often take priority, it’s worth looking at the full spectrum of marketing data. Measuring impressions might feel intangible compared to leads and revenue, but to build genuine brand loyalty we need to think about the entire customer journey, from the first interaction to the post-purchase experience. 

In doing so, we can spot gaps, address pain points and allocate resources more effectively. Are prospects aware of our brand but not considering us compared to competitors? Or do they convert quickly but then fail to become repeat customers? By analyzing each touchpoint, we can adjust strategy and investments to build strong engagements at all phases.

5. Embrace Continuous Learning

In a fast-evolving landscape, embracing continuous education is not just a strategy but a necessity. As innovations like AI and automation reshape how we connect with our audiences, marketers need to foster a mindset of curiosity and growth across every level of the organization. I encourage my teams to keep a pulse on the key trends by participating in round table discussions, reading newsletters and engaging with their marketing peers across different industries and networks.

Continuous learning empowers teams to anticipate new trends and adopt new strategies faster. As marketers, we need to ensure our people and strategies are agile enough to meet both today’s challenges and tomorrow’s opportunities.

6. Break the Rules and Experiment

Sometimes marketers need to zig while everyone else zags. Marketers should carve out a small percentage of strategic space to test entirely unfamiliar concepts that aren’t necessarily going to be backed by precedent or data. This type of marketing experimentation will help drive new innovations, and it may help brands stand out in areas where competitors are all doing the exact same things. 

Related Article: Your CX Strategy Is Broken. Here’s How Experimentation Fixes It

Remember the Why Behind Authentic Marketing

At a time when marketing automation and data present so many opportunities, it’s important that marketers don’t lose sight of their core purpose: initiating trust-based relationships with customers and prospective customers in a way that solidifies customer retention and sales. 

Understanding the “how” of effective marketing is all well and good, but we cannot push the “why” aside. It’s important to strike a balance between genuine human connection and conversions.

Learn how you can join our contributor community.